American League top to bottom
Astros, Blue Jays, Rays take top three spots in preseason rankings
I spent the past six weeks comparing the 30 current big-league clubs against 1,258 teams from the span between 1976 and 2020, better known as the era of free agency. My aim was to find trends from the past that might help us predict the future.
The process yielded the following predicted champions in the American League. Click on the links to revisit each 2023 divisional forecast:
AL East: Toronto Blue Jays
AL Central: Cleveland Guardians
AL West: Houston Astros
My predictions for 2023 are based on the next-year records for each current club’s 50 closest matches (CMs) from the past. I ranked the 15 American League clubs by the number of CMs that qualified for the playoffs in their subsequent seasons. I employed a progressive series of stats to break any ties: (1) CMs who won league titles, (2) CMs who won world championships, and (3) the current clubs’ records in 2022.
Listed below are the predicted AL rankings for 2023, based on my historical analysis. Each club’s 2022 record is followed by its winning percentage and postseason abbreviations (if applicable) of P for a playoff berth, L for a league championship, and W for a world title.
Subscribe — free — to Baseball’s Best (and Worst)
A new installment will arrive in your email each Tuesday and Friday morning
1. Houston Astros
Results for 50 closest matches: 31 playoff qualifiers, 14 league titles, 8 world championships
Forecast for 2023 regular season: 1st place in AL West
Qualify for 2023 playoffs: Yes, division champion
Record in 2022: 106-56 (.654, WLP)
2. Toronto Blue Jays
Results for 50 closest matches: 23 playoff qualifiers, 7 league titles, 3 world championships
Forecast for 2023 regular season: 1st place in AL East
Qualify for 2023 playoffs: Yes, division champion
Record in 2022: 92-70 (.568, P)
3. Tampa Bay Rays
Results for 50 closest matches: 21 playoff qualifiers, 11 league titles, 5 world championships
Forecast for 2023 regular season: 2nd place in AL East
Qualify for 2023 playoffs: Yes, wild-card qualifier
Record in 2022: 86-76 (.531, P)
4. New York Yankees
Results for 50 closest matches: 21 playoff qualifiers, 5 league titles, 2 world championships
Forecast for 2023 regular season: 3rd place in AL East
Qualify for 2023 playoffs: Yes, wild-card qualifier
Record in 2022: 99-63 (.611, P)
5. Seattle Mariners
Results for 50 closest matches: 14 playoff qualifiers, 3 league titles, 0 world championships
Forecast for 2023 regular season: 2nd place in AL West
Qualify for 2023 playoffs: Yes, wild-card qualifier
Record in 2022: 90-72 (.556, P)
6. Cleveland Guardians
Results for 50 closest matches: 14 playoff qualifiers, 1 league title, 1 world championship
Forecast for 2023 regular season: 1st place in AL Central
Qualify for 2023 playoffs: Yes, division champion
Record in 2022: 92-70 (.568, P)
7. Boston Red Sox
Results for 50 closest matches: 13 playoff qualifiers, 2 league titles, 1 world championship
Forecast for 2023 regular season: 4th place in AL East
Qualify for 2023 playoffs: No
Record in 2022: 78-84 (.481)
Cooperstown at the Crossroads
Read about the Hall of Fame’s checkered history (and uncertain future)
8. Chicago White Sox
Results for 50 closest matches: 11 playoff qualifiers, 1 league title, 1 world championship
Forecast for 2023 regular season: 2nd place in AL Central
Qualify for 2023 playoffs: No
Record in 2022: 81-81 (.500)
9. Minnesota Twins
Results for 50 closest matches: 8 playoff qualifiers, 2 league titles, 1 world championship
Forecast for 2023 regular season: 3rd place in AL Central
Qualify for 2023 playoffs: No
Record in 2022: 78-84 (.481)
10. Los Angeles Angels
Results for 50 closest matches: 8 playoff qualifiers, 2 league titles, 1 world championship
Forecast for 2023 regular season: 3rd place in AL West
Qualify for 2023 playoffs: No
Record in 2022: 73-89 (.451)
11. Baltimore Orioles
Results for 50 closest matches: 7 playoff qualifiers, 2 league titles, 0 world championships
Forecast for 2023 regular season: 5th place in AL East
Qualify for 2023 playoffs: No
Record in 2022: 83-79 (.512)
12. Texas Rangers
Results for 50 closest matches: 7 playoff qualifiers, 0 league titles, 0 world championships
Forecast for 2023 regular season: 4th place in AL West
Qualify for 2023 playoffs: No
Record in 2022: 68-94 (.420)
13. Kansas City Royals
Results for 50 closest matches: 5 playoff qualifiers, 1 league title, 1 world championship
Forecast for 2023 regular season: 4th place in AL Central
Qualify for 2023 playoffs: No
Record in 2022: 65-97 (.401)
14. Detroit Tigers
Results for 50 closest matches: 3 playoff qualifiers, 1 league title, 1 world championship
Forecast for 2023 regular season: 5th place in AL Central
Qualify for 2023 playoffs: No
Record in 2022: 66-96 (.407)
15. Oakland Athletics
Results for 50 closest matches: 3 playoff qualifiers, 0 league titles, 0 world championships
Forecast for 2023 regular season: 5th place in AL West
Qualify for 2023 playoffs: No
Record in 2022: 60-102 (.370)
Baseball’s Best (and Worst) 2023 Yearbook
A complete rundown of 2022 stats — and a look ahead at the season to come