Best batters of 2006-2010
Pujols and Cabrera are still around in 2022, but they achieved glory in the old days
Two of the greatest hitters in the period from 2006 to 2010 remain active in the major leagues more than a decade later.
Albert Pujols and Miguel Cabrera are nearing the end of the line, to be sure. Retirement seems to be imminent for both.
But they can still get the job done. A couple of examples from the current season: Pujols swatted a pair of home runs for the St. Louis Cardinals in their August 14 victory over the Milwaukee Brewers, and Cabrera went three-for-three with two runs scored on July 5, as his Detroit Tigers defeated the Cleveland Guardians.
Both players attained greatness with much greater frequency during the half-decade I’m discussing today. Pujols ranked as the best batter in the National League for the period of 2006-2010, while Cabrera finished second in the American League standings (trailing only Alex Rodriguez), based on my study of statistics in six categories.
Pujols won the NL’s Most Valuable Player Award twice during the five-year span (2008 and 2009) and was the runner-up two other years (2006 and 2010). Cabrera didn’t arrive in the AL until December 2007, when he was traded to Detroit by the Florida Marlins, but he immediately won the league’s home-run title with 37 in 2008 — and then set the pace in 2010 with 126 runs batted in.
Another important fact: Neither Pujols nor Cabrera was ever linked with performance-enhancing drugs, something that certainly can’t be said about Rodriguez.
I’ve been looking at batters in consecutive half-decades since June 17, when I started with 1961-1965, the first five-year period in the Modern Era. There are two Friday installments to come: 2011-2015 on August 26 and 2016-2020 on September 2.
The rankings for both leagues are based on my Five-Year Test, which focuses on these six stats:
Batting average
Slugging average
Runs scored per 500 plate appearances
Runs batted in per 500 plate appearances
Wins above replacement (WAR) per 500 plate appearances
The rankings for 2006-2010 encompassed every batter who crossed the minimum threshold of two plate appearances per game, the equivalent of 1,620 appearances in five 162-game seasons. (Cabrera made 2,017 appearances for the Tigers during his three AL seasons, easily meeting the requirement.)
A total of 101 batters in the American League were eligible for the Five-Year Test for 2006-2010, as were 99 hitters in the National League. The typical AL batter had a five-season batting average of .278 and a .773 ratio of bases per out. The corresponding figures in the NL were .276 and .782.
Josh Hamilton finished third behind Rodriguez and Cabrera in the AL’s 2006-2010 standings. The runners-up after Pujols in the National League were Matt Holliday and Chase Utley.
Scroll below to see my lists of the top 20 batters in each league. Each hitter is followed by a breakdown of his 2006-2010 statistics: games, hits, home runs, batting average, and bases per out. The first three stats weren’t included in the Five-Year Test, yet they’re still worthy of a look.
If you’re interested in my previous rankings, you can follow these links:
Subscribe — free — to Baseball’s Best (and Worst)
A new installment will arrive in your email each Tuesday and Friday morning
American League top batters (series so far)
1961-1965: Mickey Mantle
1966-1970: Frank Robinson
1971-1975: Reggie Jackson
1976-1980: George Brett
1981-1985: Eddie Murray
1986-1990: Rickey Henderson
1991-1995: Frank Thomas
1996-2000: Ken Griffey Jr.
2001-2005: Alex Rodriguez
2006-2010: Alex Rodriguez
National League top batters (series so far)
1961-1965: Willie Mays
1966-1970: Willie McCovey
1971-1975: Willie Stargell
1976-1980: George Foster
1981-1985: Mike Schmidt
1986-1990: Eric Davis
1991-1995: Barry Bonds
1996-2000: Larry Walker
2001-2005: Barry Bonds
2006-2010: Albert Pujols
American League top 20 batters (2006-2010)
1. Alex Rodriguez, G 711, H 771, HR 184, BA .293, BPO 1.018
2. Miguel Cabrera, G 470, H 558, HR 109, BA .314, BPO .971
3. Josh Hamilton, G 378, H 466, HR 74, BA .315, BPO .934
4. Joe Mauer, G 670, H 834, HR 66, BA .334, BPO .920
5. David Ortiz, G 704, H 721, HR 172, BA .279, BPO .991
6. Evan Longoria, G 430, H 455, HR 82, BA .283, BPO .894
7. Jim Thome, G 637, H 547, HR 159, BA .267, BPO 1.017
8. Kevin Youkilis, G 675, H 740, HR 104, BA .297, BPO .949
9. Mark Teixeira, G 608, H 663, HR 131, BA .286, BPO .943
10. Manny Ramirez, G 387, H 414, HR 76, BA .303, BPO .989
11. Justin Morneau, G 693, H 778, HR 136, BA .298, BPO .903
12. Shin-Soo Choo, G 449, H 487, HR 59, BA .300, BPO .943
13. Vladimir Guerrero, G 701, H 841, HR 131, BA .312, BPO .856
14. Magglio Ordonez, G 673, H 813, HR 94, BA .320, BPO .849
15. Robinson Cano, G 762, H 920, HR 102, BA .311, BPO .781
16. Carlos Pena, G 584, H 470, HR 145, BA .239, BPO .944
17. Carl Crawford, G 713, H 857, HR 71, BA .303, BPO .858
18. Ian Kinsler, G 618, H 668, HR 92, BA .281, BPO .848
19. Dustin Pedroia, G 556, H 667, HR 54, BA .305, BPO .826
20. Jorge Posada, G 569, H 549, HR 86, BA .288, BPO .889
National League top 20 batters (2006-2010)
1. Albert Pujols, G 768, H 918, HR 207, BA .330, BPO 1.171
2. Matt Holliday, G 673, H 854, HR 136, BA .327, BPO 1.014
3. Chase Utley, G 722, H 834, HR 134, BA .299, BPO .981
4. Chipper Jones, G 610, H 679, HR 105, BA .313, BPO 1.008
5. Joey Votto, G 456, H 511, HR 90, BA .314, BPO 1.017
6. Ryan Braun, G 579, H 711, HR 128, BA .307, BPO .935
7. Carlos Beltran, G 590, H 621, HR 118, BA .283, BPO .965
8. Hanley Ramirez, G 758, H 934, HR 124, BA .313, BPO .981
9. Ryan Howard, G 768, H 801, HR 229, BA .278, BPO .991
10. David Wright, G 775, H 896, HR 128, BA .305, BPO .952
11. Lance Berkman, G 685, H 697, HR 146, BA .289, BPO 1.009
12. Jayson Werth, G 543, H 507, HR 95, BA .282, BPO .956
13. Troy Tulowitzki, G 554, H 608, HR 92, BA .290, BPO .842
14. Aramis Ramirez, G 644, H 699, HR 131, BA .288, BPO .860
15. Adrian Gonzalez, G 799, H 856, HR 161, BA .288, BPO .884
16. Prince Fielder, G 797, H 809, HR 190, BA .279, BPO .969
17. Scott Rolen, G 427, H 429, HR 53, BA .282, BPO .808
18. Ryan Zimmerman, G 724, H 810, HR 116, BA .286, BPO .801
19. Derrek Lee, G 644, H 716, HR 104, BA .293, BPO .853
20. Brian McCann, G 695, H 702, HR 107, BA .290, BPO .835